> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://orianecohen.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Grey Zone vs Hybrid Warfare: what's the difference?
- URL: https://orianecohen.com/grey-zone-vs-hybrid-warfare/
- Published: 2026-11-16T09:41:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-22T11:37:45.000Z
- Description: One describes the tools, the other the terrain that makes them pay. Why confusing the two leads to the wrong response, read through this month’s attacks in Europe.
- Author: Oriane Cohen
- Tags: Foundations

**Quick answer.** Hybrid warfare is a way of fighting: it combines conventional and irregular means, and it can include open military force. The grey zone (also spelled gray zone) is something else: the space of competition and coercion below the threshold of open war. In the framework set out in [What is the Grey Zone?](https://orianecohen.com/the-grey-zone/), it is a structural configuration of power defined by the absence of open confrontation: power works through designed ambiguity, deniability and cognitive pressure. Hybrid tactics can appear inside a Grey Zone, but one describes the tools, the other describes the terrain that makes them pay.

In a single week of November 2026, French prosecutors attributed a cyberattack on supermarket refrigeration systems to Iran's Revolutionary Guard, an Estonian drone maker was targeted by an attempted sabotage, and hoax bomb threats disrupted flights and schools across Europe.

Almost every headline used the same two words, often in the same sentence: hybrid, and grey zone (or gray zone).

They are not synonyms.

Treating them as one is an analytical error, and it produces the wrong responses.

I have worked as a war reporter and as a HUMINT operator. That work taught me that the tools are the easy part to see... The environment that lets those tools work, without anyone being forced to answer, is what decides the outcome.

---

## What is hybrid warfare?

Hybrid warfare is a method of conflict that combines several kinds of means at once. NATO describes hybrid threats as combining "military and non-military as well as covert and overt means", used "to blur the lines between war and peace".

In practice, the hybrid toolbox includes:

- sabotage of infrastructure, physical or digital;
- drones over military and industrial sites;
- proxies, criminals and recruited locals who carry out acts for a foreign service;
- disinformation and hoaxes designed to overload institutions;
- economic and energy coercion;
- and, when needed, regular military force alongside all of the above.

Hybrid warfare does not stop where open war begins. Russia's war in Ukraine is hybrid in its practice: tanks and missiles on one side yes, but also sabotage, cyber and influence on the other. Hybrid is about the combination of means.

It says nothing, by itself, about whether the conflict is declared.

That's where the confusion starts. Many outlets now define hybrid warfare as "malign activity below the threshold of war that often lacks a clear perpetrator", to quote Defense News in November 2026.

The problem with that sentence is that it does not describe a method. It describes an environment: below a threshold, without a clear author. That is the Grey Zone.

---

## [What is the Grey Zone?](https://orianecohen.com/the-grey-zone/)

The Grey Zone is a structural configuration of power that emerges in fragmented, interdependent systems. In it, actors pursue their goals through designed ambiguity, deniability and cognitive pressure rather than open confrontation. It is not a tactic. It is the shape of the terrain.

Five conditions must all be present:

1. **Liminality**: the situation sits between clear categories, neither war nor peace, neither crime nor act of state.
2. **Strategic ambiguity**: uncertainty is deliberately maintained, not accidental.
3. **Non-attribution**: no actor can be publicly and definitively held responsible.
4. **Cognitive targeting**: perception and decision-making are the real target.
5. **Multi-vectorial pressure**: pressure arrives through several channels at once.

If one condition is missing, you are not in a Grey Zone. A declared war fails the first. A sabotage claimed openly by a state fails the third.

The Grey Zone also applies well beyond states. The same five conditions can be found in geopolitics, inside organisations, between people and inside a single mind. A boardroom power play can meet all five. A tank column cannot.

I set out the full model in [The Grey Zone (definition)](https://orianecohen.com/the-grey-zone-definition/) and in the working paper *The Grey Zone: A Structural Model of Power under Complexity* ([DOI](https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24131716?ref=orianecohen.com)).

---

## Grey Zone vs hybrid warfare: what is the actual difference?

Hybrid warfare answers the question *how* an actor applies pressure. The Grey Zone answers *where* and *why* that pressure works without triggering a response.

| Hybrid warfare     | The Grey Zone                             |                                                            |
| ------------------ | ----------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------- |
| What it is         | A method: a combination of means          | A configuration of power: a terrain                        |
| Open force         | Can include it                            | Defined by its absence                                     |
| Attribution        | Often known, sometimes claimed            | Kept impossible to prove in public                         |
| Who                | Mostly states and their proxies           | Any actor: states, companies, groups, individuals          |
| Domains            | Military, cyber, economic, informational  | Geopolitical, organisational, interpersonal, psychological |
| Main target        | Capabilities, infrastructure, will        | Perception and decision-making                             |
| Success looks like | A military or political objective reached | No response, or the wrong one                              |

Two consequences follow.

First, hybrid tools can leave the Grey Zone. When an actor claims its sabotage, or escalates to open fighting, the method stays hybrid but the terrain changes. Ambiguity is gone, and so is the protection it offered.

Second, the Grey Zone can exist without any "warfare" at all. A takeover prepared through quiet pressure on a board, or a rumour that slowly isolates a rival, meets all five conditions without a single weapon.

This is why the confusion is costly. If you call everything hybrid warfare, you look for a military answer to what is a structural problem. You count incidents instead of reading the configuration that makes them cheap.

---

## What do these attacks look like in Europe in 2026?

Three cases from the same week show the difference better than any definition. Read each one twice: once for the tool, once for the terrain.

### **France: the refrigerators.**

Hundreds of refrigeration systems were hit, more than 700 supermarkets and grocery stores were affected and about 20 fires followed, according to the Soufan Center's summary of the case. The Paris prosecutor attributed the attack to members of the IRGC's Electronic and Cyber Center. France's foreign minister called it "the first large-scale cyberattack carried out for the purpose of sabotage on national territory".

- The tool: cyber sabotage against civilian infrastructure. Clearly hybrid.
- The terrain: the target was daily life, not a military site. The attribution came from a prosecutor, after the fact. Between the attack and the attribution, the Grey Zone did its work: confusion, delay, no response.

### **Estonia: the drone maker.**

On 14 November, an attempted sabotage targeted Threod Systems, an Estonian drone manufacturer. Prime Minister Kristen Michal said it was ordered by Russian military intelligence and called it "part of Russia's broader hybrid war against Europe".

- The tool: physical sabotage, aimed at causing an explosion and a fire.
- The terrain: a political attribution by a head of government, which the accused state can simply deny. The act is named; the author is not proven in a way that forces a collective answer.

### **Across Europe: the bomb hoaxes.**

Hoax threats targeted flights to and from Lisbon, Rome, Prague and Sofia, and thousands of schools in Italy, Ireland and the UK.

- The tool: almost nothing. A message costs nothing to send.
- The terrain: pure Grey Zone. No damage, no author, and yet cancelled flights, evacuated schools, and institutions forced to spend their attention.

The more an act is attributed, the more it becomes "hybrid warfare" that states can answer. The less it is attributed, the more it belongs to the Grey Zone, where the cheapest acts produce the most disruption.

### Why does nobody claim these attacks?

Because in the Grey Zone, non-attribution is THE weapon.

An attack that is claimed can be answered. An attack that is only suspected forces every target into an impossible position: respond without proof and look aggressive, or wait for proof and look weak. Meanwhile, the attacker keeps acting. Time, proof and the political cost of naming someone are the real battlefield.

When I prepared the [2027 Strategic Outlook](https://orianecohen.com/2027-outlook/), I listed the actions that no one had claimed, or that had been attributed too late to matter. That list is what makes the coming year hard to read.

Non-attribution also shifts the burden onto you.

If nobody tells you who did it, you have to decide for yourself whether an event is a hostile operation or bad luck. And you therefore have to decide how you personally adapt to it. Or how your company will adapt in the volatile and unstable markets.

That is a skill, and it can be trained. You can test yours with the [attribution test](https://orianecohen.com/attribution-test/), and read how these attacks are getting cheaper and quieter in [the new targets nobody claims](https://orianecohen.com/the-new-targets-nobody-claims/).

---

## How should you read the next "hybrid attack" headline?

The next incident will come with the same words. Before you accept them, ask three questions.

1. **Is there open force, or a claimed author?** If yes, you are looking at hybrid warfare that can be answered as such. If no, ask what the ambiguity is buying, and for whom.
2. **What was the real target?** The server, the factory or the flight is the visible target. The real one is often a decision: to send weapons, to keep a supplier, to trust an institution, to stay calm.
3. **Is this an incident or a pattern?** One fire is an accident. A series of small, cheap, unclaimed acts against daily life is a configuration. Look for the pattern, not the event.

For organisations, the practical consequence is simple. Do not wait for attribution to act. Plan for the effect, whoever the author turns out to be.

For individuals, it means protecting your judgment as much as your devices. That is what [cognitive security](https://orianecohen.com/cognitive-security/) is about, and I have set out the first steps in [how to protect yourself from cognitive warfare](https://orianecohen.com/how-to-protect-yourself-from-cognitive-warfare/).

---

### FAQ

**Is hybrid warfare an act of war?** Not automatically. NATO has said since 2016 that hybrid actions against an Ally could lead to a decision to invoke Article 5\. Whether they do is a political choice, made case by case.

**What does "below the threshold of war" mean?** It describes actions designed to cause harm without crossing the line that would justify an open military response. The threshold is not fixed: each state draws it differently, and Grey Zone actors work precisely in that uncertainty.

**What are examples of hybrid attacks in Europe in 2026?** In November 2026 alone: a cyberattack on refrigeration systems in French supermarkets attributed to the IRGC, an attempted sabotage of an Estonian drone maker, and waves of hoax bomb threats against flights and schools.

**Is it "gray zone” or “grey zone"?** Both are correct. "Gray" is the American spelling, "grey" the British and international one.

**How does cognitive warfare relate to the Grey Zone?** Cognitive warfare targets how people perceive, interpret and decide. Cognitive targeting is one of the five conditions of the Grey Zone, which is why most Grey Zone operations are, at their core, cognitive. See [what is cognitive warfare](https://orianecohen.com/cognitive-warfare/).

---

Go deeper: [What is the Grey Zone?](https://orianecohen.com/the-grey-zone/) · [What is cognitive warfare?](https://orianecohen.com/cognitive-warfare/) · [The rise of invisible warfare](https://orianecohen.com/the-rise-of-invisible-warfare-why-the-next-war-wont-be-declared/)

Sources:

- [NATO, Countering hybrid threats](https://www.nato.int/cps/en/natohq/topics%5F156338.htm?ref=orianecohen.com)
- [The Soufan Center, IntelBrief, 13 November 2026](https://thesoufancenter.org/intelbrief-2026-november-13/?ref=orianecohen.com)
- [Euronews, Estonian drone maker targeted in 'GRU-ordered' sabotage attempt, 15 November 2026](https://www.euronews.com/2026/11/15/estonian-drone-maker-targeted-by-gru-ordered-sabotage-attempt-pm-says?ref=orianecohen.com)
- [Defense News, US European Command launches vigilance campaign as hybrid threats mount, 6 November 2026](https://www.defensenews.com/news/2026/11/06/us-european-command-launches-vigilance-campaign-as-hybrid-threats-mount/?ref=orianecohen.com)
- Cohen, O. (2026). *The Grey Zone: A Structural Model of Power under Complexity*. [doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24131716](https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24131716?ref=orianecohen.com)