There is a peculiar mistake people make when trying to influence you: they focus entirely on what they want you to see.
Be it the credential, the threat, the compliment, the urgency or the carefully selected piece of information.
What they fail to realise is that while they are trying to modify your perception of them, they are simultaneously giving you information... about themselves.
Here, people like me become slightly inconvenient.
You cannot spend years working with human sources, deception, influence and competing versions of reality without developing a reflexive relationship with human interaction.
While I listen to what someone is saying, part of my attention inevitably moves to the interaction itself.
Why this argument? Why now? Why this particular piece of information? Why mention that person? Why suddenly introduce urgency? Why assume that would matter to me?
The fact that I speak openly about these subjects online brings an interesting assortment of people into my orbit.
Some I work with. Some become friends or collaborators. Some want information. Some want access. Others want to recruit me, associate me with their organisation, bring me into their network, or simply move me closer to whatever outcome they have in mind.
Most of this is normal. Human relationships are full of influence. There is nothing inherently sinister about wanting someone to join you, trust you, work with you or change their mind.
But recently, in several completely unrelated situations, I noticed something that amused me.
Someone would try to influence me using a particular lever. And the lever itself would become more interesting to me than whatever they were trying to obtain.
The funniest instances are when this comes from people who present themselves as experts in intelligence, influence, "cognitive warfare", psychological profiling or adjacent fields.
Because expertise in the vocabulary of influence does not necessarily translate into psychological finesse, to say the least.
So you find yourself watching someone deploy status against a person who is... indifferent to status. Or scarcity against someone who is comfortable walking away. Or institutional access against someone who deliberately built her career outside institutions. Or belonging against someone comfortable not belonging.
They believe they are profiling you.
But the method they selected to influence you has started profiling them. That is the part of influence we discuss surprisingly little.
Every influence attempt is also an information leak.
In what follows, I want to look at influence as a two-way information exchange: first at the message, then at the choice of leverage behind it; at what that choice reveals about someone's model of you and where projection enters when that model is incomplete; then at behavioral anomalies, unnecessary lies and contradictions.
My argument is simple:
If you only analyse what people tell you, you are leaving information on the table.
The interaction itself is the intelligence.
- Every influence attempt contains two messages
- Where their model of you ends, projection begins
- The unnecessary lie
- Contradictions should not be resolved prematurely
- A survival guide for operating in the grey (15 things you should NEVER do with a Grey Zone Operator)
On August 23, the Summer 2026 offer on The Grey Zone disappears.
Until then, get 26% off your annual subscription and unlock the complete archive, original research, and every upcoming publication.
Cognitive warfare, HUMINT, strategic intelligence, perception, influence and geopolitics... built to be read deeper than a 5-minute scroll.
Every influence attempt contains two messages
Every attempt to influence another human being contains, at minimum, two streams of information:
1) The obvious one: the message itself
2) The less obvious: the choice of mechanism used to deliver the message.
Let's take someone repeatedly emphasising their proximity to powerful people.
When most people would rightfully ask "is this person actually influential?", I tend to wonder: "why do they believe that proximity to power is important for me to know?".
Those are very different questions.
Perhaps the person genuinely has influence. Perhaps they are compensating for having very little. Perhaps they operate in an environment where status determines access and assume yours works the same way. Perhaps they think they have identified status sensitivity in you. Or perhaps status is the lever that would work... on them?
You don't know yet.
A behavior is not a definitive answer. It is more like a hypothesis generator from which you can start working on.
The same applies to threats.
If someone threatens to exclude you from a network, remove access, damage your reputation or close a professional door, don't only evaluate whether the threat is credible.
Look at the leverage they selected. They have just told you something about their model of you. They believe you need what they think they control.
Now you have useful questions to work with!
Why do they believe that? What previous behavior of yours produced that assessment? Is this leverage specific to you, or do they use it habitually?What does their choice of leverage reveal about the environment in which they themselves operate?
This is where influence becomes profiling.
Projection is the amateur manipulator's weakness
Sophisticated influence requires modelling another mind.
You identify what the other person values, fears, protects, desires and cannot afford to lose. Then you adapt, accordingly.
But humans are imperfect profilers.
When information about another person is incomplete, we naturally fill the gaps with ourselves.
We assume others care about the things we care about. We imagine they fear what we fear. We offer incentives we would find attractive. We threaten losses we would find painful. We expect social mechanisms that govern us to govern them too.
This creates one of the great ironies of manipulation: the person attempting to profile you may accidentally profile... themselves.
Someone who consistently uses exclusion as leverage may be revealing the importance of belonging in their own model of the world.
Someone obsessed with demonstrating credentials may inhabit a hierarchy where legitimacy comes from institutional recognition.
The lever they reach for by default is the lever that would work on them. Where their model of you runs out, they hand you a map of themselves.
The unnecessary lie
Someone who lies when the truth would have served perfectly well is perhaps the most interesting case.
I am talking about perfectly trivial lies. Useless lies.
Sometimes the lie concerns something so insignificant that discovering it leaves you with a difficult question: "why? why would they do that at all?"
I dealt with something like this recently.
A client discovered that someone he trusted had betrayed him in a fairly consequential way. As we started reconstructing what happened, something appeared: not ONE lie designed to conceal the betrayal, but a pile of them. Lie after lie after lie after lie...
Some were understandable in purely instrumental terms.
What caught my attention were the other lies. The little ones. My client was still processing the betrayal and asked: "but why would he do that?"
I find this question fascinating.
It assumes that the lie must "make sense" from our model of the situation. If there is no obvious benefit, why incur the risk of lying?
But that's precisely what is interesting with human psychology! When deception appears unnecessary, you have discovered that your model of the person's incentives is incomplete.
Maybe the lie is protecting something you have not identified yet. Maybe the trivial detail connects to another fact you don't have. Maybe the person is managing several narratives with different people and has lost track of which version belongs where. Maybe deception has become habitual because previous lies require continuous maintenance. Or maybe there is another explanation entirely ?
Again, you don't know. And "I don't know" is considerably more useful than a premature psychological diagnosis.
What you do know is that the economics of the behavior have changed.
A lie normally has a cost: cognitive effort, exposure risk, reputational damage if discovered, and the burden of maintaining consistency. If someone repeatedly pays that cost where you cannot identify a corresponding benefit, that is information.
Do not dismiss the lie because the subject is trivial. Interrogate the fact that the lie was worth telling.
Contradictions should not be resolved prematurely
Most people experience contradictions as irritating obstacles to understanding.
George says X on Monday and Y on Thursday. Which one is true?
Premature question!
You don't need to resolve the contradiction immediately. Contradiction itself is a useful information. For a while, hold both as a working state you are willing to stay in.
George said X. George said Y. Do not reconcile them yet. Do not decide that one statement represents the "real George" and the other is an anomaly.
Contradictions have "kinds". And kind is the intelligence.
Maybe George was relaying a position that was never his own, and you mistook a borrowed opinion for a conviction. Maybe he changed his mind between Monday and Thursday, and both statements are sincere. Maybe one of them was never meant to be taken literally. Maybe there is a condition he never spelled out, and the moment you have it, the two statements stop contradicting each other at all.
Or maybe the contradiction is deliberate. Maybe George keeps X for one audience and Y for another, by design, and has arranged things so that no single listener is ever placed to hold both at once. Most listeners never are.
The ordinary listener treats a contradiction as the speaker's failure. But a contradiction can be the speaker's method too, and it stays invisible to everyone who resolves it too quickly.
The one who refuses to smooth it away is the only one still reading it.
So you do not know yet. And "I don't know" is not a gap to fill in a hurry. The most you can honestly say is what the situation is not. Which is already more disciplined than a confident portrait assembled from too little.
A great deal of bad profiling comes from our intolerance for unresolved states. We want people to be coherent. Honest or dishonest. Loyal or disloyal. Confident or insecure. Friend or adversary.
We collect behaviors and gradually assemble them into a person. Then when something does not fit, instead of questioning the person we have assembled, we explain away the inconvenient piece.
What we are doing is protecting our model from reality.
The representation you built to understand someone begins determining which new observations you are willing to accept about them.
This is particularly dangerous with people we know well, and the people we love. Familiarity produces enormous confidence and surprisingly little epistemic discipline.
"I know him. He would never do that."
No. You know a set of behaviours observed under a particular range of conditions. You know how this person behaved with you, around certain people, under certain incentives, while particular costs and rewards were in place. Change the conditions and you may meet a version of the same person your existing model never had to account for.
This is why, after everything from affairs and elaborate frauds to serial killers cases, the people closest to the person so often appear genuinely stunned.
Contradiction should create friction. Friction is healthy and necessary.
A short survival guide for operating in the grey
Influence is highly contextual. On most people, in most rooms, the standard levers land. Pick your target well and you will usually get what you came for.
Usually.
There is a category you should learn to spot before you decide to work someone. They live in the grey zone, and they are comfortable there. Against them the levers may invert.
So take the list below whichever way it applies to you. A warning, if you work on people for a living. Or a mirror because maybe you are not the one being influenced in this exchange.
Here are 15 things you should NEVER do with a Grey Zone Operator
1- Lie unnecessarily. We will wonder why you needed the lie and start reverse-engineering your motive.
2- Try to impress us with status, credentials or proximity to power. We couldn't care less about your titles. We're more interested in who actually influences the decision-maker than in who sits next to them.
3- Misrepresent our argument. We will notice whether it was deliberate or whether you genuinely failed to understand it. You really don't want to do that deliberately.
4- Fill an uncomfortable silence. We may be collecting information. And you will probably reveal more than you intended.
5- Give us contradictory information. Contradictions attract our attention rather than confuse us.
6- Give us too much information. We connect weak signals faster than you expect.
7- Use jargon to disguise your shallow thinking. We will keep drilling until we reach the mechanism. Or discover and expose there isn't one.
8- Assume your (moral) framework is our framework. We switch perspectives easily and will always look for the option your framing conveniently excluded.
9- Confuse rules with reality. Formal structures and actual power structures frequently diverge. We care about the latter.
10- Try to overwhelm us with complexity or destabilize us with ambiguity. You may accidentally create the environment in which we perform best.
11- Mistake empathy for sympathy. Understanding your emotional state does not mean we are being governed by it.
12- Try to create dependency. We are sensitive to anything that reduces our optionality.
13- Assume we need to belong. We don't. Exclusion is a weak leverage against someone comfortable operating as a lone wolf.
14- Threaten our access to the table. No worries. We may simply build another one.
15- Tell us something is impossible. We don't accept "impossible" as an answer.
Every strategy you use to influence someone reveals something about you. The status you display, the lie you choose, the silence you cannot tolerate, the leverage you assume will work.
Choose your lever carefully.
Stay lucid,
Oriane
Go deeper: What is the Grey Zone? · What is cognitive warfare?
Learn to protect your judgment
Cognitive security is not a theory you read about; it is a practice. The Grey Zone Protocol is my cognitive security training: five modules to see how your perception is shaped, test your first reading, recognise manipulation and decide when information is incomplete. 47 hours, self-paced, built from war reporting and human intelligence.
If this perspective resonated, it’s because it’s part of a longer line of work.
I publish one structured analysis each week. If you want to follow this work week after week, click the button below.