Skip to content
10 min read The Grey Zone's latest briefs

Why the world suddenly needed "cognitive warfare"

An investigation into the rise of one of the most influential - and misunderstood -concepts in modern strategy.

Why the world suddenly needed "cognitive warfare"

Somewhere between 2020 and 2025, "cognitive warfare" became one of the most fashionable concepts in national security.

Governments have strategies.
Think tanks publish reports.
Universities launch research programs.

Everyone seems convinced "cognitive warfare" is one of the defining challenges of the XXIst century.

Why did the world suddenly NEED the concept of cognitive warfare?

Concepts don't suddenly become fashionable by accident. Especially not in national security.

A concept becomes dominant because institutions need it. Once adopted, it reorganizes budgets, research agendas, military doctrine, university programs and entire professional ecosystems.

To understand why the world needed that concept, I started investigating.

Unlike most of the literature on the topic, I did not begin in libraries. For years, I participated in what many people would now call "cognitive warfare".

To be honest, we never used that expression. In fact, we rarely named what we were doing at all. We were doing the job without debating its ethical or intellectual meaning.

The luxury of theory is to name things. The constraint of operations is to act before they are named. So by the time academics begin debating definitions, operators have been exploiting those mechanisms for years.

I started with operations and asked later what concept, if any, could explain what I had done and seen.

After reading hundreds of pages about it... I am not convinced the people writing about cognitive warfare understand what they are describing.

Before we start, I will warn you. This essay is a "mise en abyme". By the time you finish reading it, you will have experienced the very mechanism it describes.

For its duration, you are going to borrow my way of seeing reality. By the end, you will understand what kind of transaction that was and why whoever controls that transaction, at scale, controls more than any army does.


TL;DR


Explore the series

  1. Why the world suddenly needed “cognitive warfare”, July 2026
  2. Cognitive warfare: from reflexive control to cognitive climate, July 2026
  3. The blind spot of cognitive warfare, August 2026
  4. A dangerous information environment contains no lies, August 2026
  5. No, your mind isn’t the battlefield, September 2026
  6. Naming is Not Knowing, Small Wars Journal, September 2026

Nobody invented cognitive warfare: the genealogy of a concept

Or at least, not in the way many people assume. The practices themselves are ancient.

25 centuries ago, Sun Tzu opened The Art of War with the axiom that all war rests on deception, and ranked subduing the enemy without fighting above any victory won in battle.

A few centuries later, Kautilya's Arthashastra described disinformation, agents of influence and the deliberate creation of divisions as ordinary instruments of statecraft.

The Hebrew Bible is filled with stories of rulers, spies, prophets and military leaders winning (or avoiding wars) by deception, intelligence, psychological pressure and the strategic shaping of perception.

Shaping perception, influencing decisions, weakening morale, creating uncertainty, exploiting fear: none of this is new.

What is new is the language around it.

I set out to identify the first appearance of the expression cognitive warfare.

One of the earliest documented military uses appears in a 1996 thesis by Arden Dahl, where the term is discussed within the context of command-and-control warfare. At the time, the term attracted little attention.

It would take another two decades before cognitive warfare entered mainstream strategic thinking.

But without naming it as such: the Soviets had already mathematized it in the 1960s.

Vladimir Lefebvre, a mathematician and psychologist working at the intersection of cybernetics and game theory, formalized reflexive control: transmitting specially prepared information to an adversary so that he voluntarily makes the decision you have predetermined for him.

France published La guerre cognitive (The Cognitive Warfare), edited by Christian Harbulot and Didier Lucas at the École de Guerre Économique, in 2002. 18 years before NATO institutionalized it.

China doctrinalized in two waves: the "3 warfares" formally adopted in 2003; then, from the late 2010s, "cognitive domain operations" aiming at what PLA theorists call "command of the mind".

The United States had its own kind of lineage: "perception management" as a Pentagon term, command-and-control warfare in the 1990s (Dahl's thesis), Information Operations doctrine (1998). Then DARPA took the neuroscientific turn with a program built to quantify the influence of narratives on human cognition.

Now look at the shape of this: it is a LOOP.

The Chinese theorize in response to the Americans. Harbulot writes against American dominance. Russian authors suspect the very concept of "information warfare" of being an American reflexive-control operation designed to make Moscow overinvest in a domain beyond its reach.

For 60 years, each power theorized its reflection in the other's mirror. Nobody is the origin.

Cognitive warfare was not "invented". It was assembled.

It inherited pieces from psychological warfare, information warfare, cyber, behavioural science, cognitive psychology, influence operations, strategic communications and neurosciences.

Each field contributed part of the vocabulary. Each built to solve a different problem. That also explains why definitions vary so dramatically. Different communities are describing different phenomena while using the same expression.

The label "cognitive warfare" became an umbrella.

In 2020, the Innovation Hub - a Norfolk-based structure sponsored by NATO's Allied Command Transformation - published François du Cluzel's report Cognitive Warfare.

And almost overnight, "cognitive warfare" became a category.

Research programs appeared. Think tanks began publishing. Governments adopted the vocabulary.


Why 2020?

The honest answer to "why 2020" has two layers.

The first layer is trivial: an institutional trigger. The du Cluzel report gave the concept a NATO "stamp", and bureaucracies replicate what NATO stamps.

The second layer is more interesting: by 2020, several structural transformations, each unfolding independently, had matured to the point where decision-makers could no longer describe their environment with inherited categories.

These transformations are not equal in weight. Two of them are drivers. Two are accelerants. Two are revealers.

The two drivers.

The platform age reached maturity. For the first time in history, a handful of private companies became the primary infrastructure through which billions of people perceive reality. Governments no longer controlled the public square.

The crisis of authority. For most of the XXth century, authority and legitimacy flowed through institutions. By 2020, that hierarchy had fractured. Today, almost anyone can manufacture credibility at extraordinary speed. Reputation has become cheap to build, easy to amplify, and difficult to verify.

The two accelerants.

Artificial intelligence. AI altered the scale. Information can be generated, translated, personalized and distributed faster than any human organization can realistically verify.

The return of great power competition. After 9/11, Western security thinking was dominated by counterterrorism. Then the focus shifted: China, Russia, technology, supply chains, critical infrastructure, influence. Cognitive warfare fits that landscape.

The two revealers.

COVID-19 Pandemic. Obviously. This deserves a full case study of its own; I will publish one separately.

The collapse of disciplinary boundaries. Psychology, behavioural science, neuroscience, cyber, information warfare, strategic communications... "Cognitive warfare" became a meeting point more than a precise concept.

Taken individually, none of these developments explains the emergence of the concept. Together, they explain why it became indispensable.


The word nobody defines: cognition

What nobody asks is why the field settled on that particular word.

Words organize reality. Every word tells us what to observe, measure, fund, defend and ignore.

Calling something "information warfare" directs attention toward information. Calling it "psychological warfare" directs attention toward emotions. Calling it "cyber warfare" directs attention toward infrastructure.

"Cognitive warfare" shifts attention toward something more abstract.

The field borrows the word "cognition" from science then proceeds as if cognition required no explanation. This is not a minor omission.

If we cannot agree on what cognition is, it becomes difficult to agree on what cognitive warfare targets.

NATO defines cognitive warfare as:

Other authors focus on decision-making.

Some emphasize perception. Others behaviour. Others beliefs. Others attention. Others the brain itself.

Read enough reports and they begin to blur into one another. The same words keep returning as if they were interchangeable.

Problem: they are not.

Why cognition rather than propaganda? Propaganda sounds ideological. Cognition sounds scientific.

Why cognition rather than manipulation? Manipulation raises moral questions. Cognition sounds descriptive.

The word itself performs an extraordinary... cognitive operation. By sounding scientific, it depoliticizes the debate without changing the phenomenon.

It becomes even more interesting when we ask: where does cognition actually happen?

The literrature assumes: inside the brain. Therefore, the battlefield is the mind.

But does that assumption truly hold?

Consider how strategic decisions are made today.

No president reads the world directly. No CEO observes markets directly. Reality reaches them through filters: reports, dashboards, algorithms, analysts, social media, experts... What they call "reality" is the product of multiple layers of interpretation before it reaches conscious thought.

Cognition, in practice, is distributed. The brain depends on external systems to construct a usable representation of reality.

This claim is one cognitive science has been making for 3 decades: Edwin Hutchins called it distributed cognition; Andy Clark and David Chalmers called it the extended mind.

What is strange is that a field which names itself after cognition has ignored what science actually says about where cognition happens.


What operations teach that papers don't

Over the years, I have been involved in different kind of "influence operations". Some were targeting individuals. Some were targeting groups of people.

When you are paid to seed an idea that will ultimately change a decision, you understand quickly the more important the target, the less effective direct persuasion tends to be. You have to make your target believe the idea came from them.

Like an "inception".

To seed a complex idea into someone's head, you never touch their head. You engineer the environment around the individual until a conclusion appears self-evident.

That requires working on multiple environmental layers simultaneously.

Depending on the case you'd use the trusted adviser, the spouse raising the same concern. You'd add some signals, "coincidences" that will reinforce the perception that something is changing.

None of these interventions needs to determine the decision on its own. What matters is the convergence. Eventually, the individual experiences the conclusion as entirely their own.

Which brings me back to what cognition is:

If changing a decision requires changing the environment in which reality is constructed, then cognition cannot be understood as a process occurring solely inside the brain. It emerges from an interaction between the individual AND the environment through which that individual encounters reality.

This distinction becomes decisive once we move from influencing one person to influencing millions.

Engineering the environment around a single decision-maker is slow, targeted, human.

Engineering the environment around entire populations was, until recently, almost impossible: no actor could orchestrate that many layers at once. Digital infrastructures changed that.

This is why cognition is distributed. Because the construction of reality depends on systems outside the individual.

If this diagnosis is correct, then most cognitive warfare theorists are wrong. The primarily battlefield is not the mind. The target is the ecology that produces the mind's picture of the world.


Delegated perception

Take the human brain as an economic system.

Every cognitive process has a cost: observation costs, memory costs, attention costs.

Throughout history, whenever constructing an accurate representation of reality became too costly, humans delegated the task.

We delegated cosmology to religion. Navigation to sailors. Memory to writing.
Geography to maps. Knowledge to universities. News to journalists.

Delegated perception is one of the oldest mechanisms of civilization.

What has changed is the economics of delegation. The informational cost of constructing reality has exploded. The amount of potentially relevant information now exceeds any individual's capacity to observe, verify and integrate it.

Delegating perception is a natural and adaptive response to complexity.

Yet we constantly hear the same advice.

Think critically.
Verify the sources.
Do your own research.

Bullshit. It sounds responsible. But it also reveals that most people giving these advices have never had to produce reliable intelligence under constraints.

I spent years as a journalist and later in intelligence. Let me tell you something: nobody verifies everything. Nobody can.

Verify what?

Every source? Every dataset? Every detail of a geopolitical event? Every translation? Every video?

You'd need multiple lifetimes to do so without ever reaching a conclusion. Even intelligence agencies don't work that way.

It is a fantasy to believe absolute autonomous perception is possible.

Think about what you are doing right now. You are reading these words because, at least for the duration of this essay, you judged that my way of observing and interpreting reality might help you understand a phenomenon.

You are not surrendering your judgment. You are borrowing part of mine. That is delegated perception.

Every day, we all do exactly the same thing. With journalists, analysts. Increasingly, with AI. None of this is inherently pathological.

Unconscious delegated perception is the problem.

To whom do we delegate? On what basis? How often? With what safeguards?

These questions are important because whoever becomes indispensable to another person's construction of reality acquires extraordinary power and influence over their decisions.


The symptom and the structure

Most analyses treat cognitive warfare as the phenomenon to be explained. I do not. I see it as ONE visible manifestation of how power operates in fragmented, interconnected, information-saturated systems.

This is what I call the Grey Zone, in its most complete definition: the structural architecture through which power operates under complexity.

Cognitive warfare is a category of practices: it names a class of actions certain actors take against certain targets.

The Grey Zone is a description of the terrain: the conditions under which such practices become dominant, cheap, and hard to counter.

One names what is done. The other names the environment that makes it worth doing. Confusing the two is like confusing "naval warfare" with "the ocean."

So instead of wondering how to protect yourself against cognitive warfare, learn the terrain. The work is more demanding, but it's much more useful.

Stay lucid,

Oriane

Go deeper: What is cognitive warfare?

Learn to protect your judgment

Cognitive security is not a theory you read about; it is a practice. The Grey Zone Protocol is my cognitive security training: five modules to see how your perception is shaped, test your first reading, recognise manipulation and decide when information is incomplete. 47 hours, self-paced, built from war reporting and human intelligence.

Discover the Protocol
this is a public article.

If this perspective resonated, it’s because it’s part of a longer line of work.

I publish one structured analysis each week. If you want to follow this work week after week, click the button below.

→ Receive the next analysis.